SURVIVOR: WC vs BC vs NC – 3/4/15 | Survivor

Bryan’s Rankings of the Top 125(ish) Players in Survivor History

So, if you don’t recall, I went back and watched every episode of Survivor and studied every challenge ever played and every idol ever found, and every everything… I don’t like subjective lists of “who’s the best player ever” because it’s just so…subjective. You wanna know who wins the MLB Triple Crown? Check the stats. Who wins the Home Run title? Check the stats. Who wins the MVP and Cy Young awards? Ok, disregard those… But what I offer you is the most worthy players in Survivor history. The ones who excelled not only in their seasons, but in comparison to every other season. And since it’s been a while, here’s a recap of the scoring:

The Categories:
-Days on the “island”
-Reward Challenges (Tribe) won
-Reward Challenges (Individual/Post-Merge) won
-Exile Arena win
-Immunity Challenges (Tribe) won or “gifted”
-Immunity Challenges (Individual) won or “granted”
-Hidden Immunity or “Special” Idols found or “gifted”
-Redemption Island duels won or “survived”
-Final tribal council non-winners
-Sole Survivors

Points deducted for:
-Medically Evacuated
-Quitter

Maybe I should re-evaluate how many points are deducted for quitting, because in Survivor, there’s really nothing worse than that. I’ll think about it. But without further ado, here are the top 125ish players of all time, their points earned, and the seasons they competed in…

Rank	Pts.	Name	Season(s)
1	215	(Boston) Rob Mariano	Marq., All-Stars, HvV, Redemption Is.
2	194	Oscar “Ozzy” Lusth	Cook Is., Micronesia, South Pacific
3	185	Parvati Shallow	Cook Is., Micronesia, HvV
4	173	Amanda Kimmel	China, Micronesia, HvV
5	159	Colby Donaldson	Aus. Outback, All-Stars, HvV
6	154	Rupert Boneham	Pearl Is., All-Stars, HvV, BvW
7	149	Tyson Apostol	Tocantins, HvV, BvW
8	147	Russell Hantz	Samoa, HvV, Redemption Is.
9	143	Benjamin “Coach” Wade	Tocantins, HvV, South Pacific
10	125	Jerri Manthey	Aus. Outback, All-Stars, HvV
11	124	Jonathan Penner	Cook Is., Micronesia, Philippines
12	119	Malcolm Freberg	Philippines, Caramoan
13	118	Erik Reichenbach	Micronesia, Caramoan
13	118	John Cochran	South Pacific, Caramoan
13	118	Sandra Diaz-Twine	Pearl Is., HvV
16	115	James “J.T.” Thomas, Jr.	Tocantins, HvV
17	114	Gervase Peterson	Borneo, BvW
18	112	Andrea Boehlke	Redemption Is., Caramoan
18	112	James Clement	China, Micronesia, HvV
20	111	Tina Wesson	Aus. Outback, All-Stars, BvW
21	108	Danielle DiLorenzo	Panama, HvV
22	107	Amber Brkich	Aus. Outback, All-Stars
22	107	Candice Woodcock-Cody	Cook Is., HvV, BvW
24	106	Cirie Fields	Panama, Micronesia, HvV
25	104	Aras Baskauskas	Panama, BvW
25	104	Tom Buchanan	Africa, All-Stars
27	102	Kathy Vavrick-O’Brien	Marq., All-Stars
27	102	Tom Westman	Palau, HvV
29	101	Brenda Lowe	Nicaragua, Caramoan
29	101	Laura Morett	Samoa, BvW
31	100	Stephenie LaGrossa	Palau, Guatemala, HvV
32	99	Eliza Orlins	Vanuatu, Micronesia
33	98	Dawn Meehan	South Pacific, Caramoan
34	97	Lex van den Berghe	Africa, All-Stars
35	96	Phillip Sheppard	Redemption Is., Caramoan
36	91	Michael Skupin	Aus. Outback, Philippines
37	87	Jenna Lewis	Borneo, All-Stars
38	86	Ethan Zohn	Africa, All-Stars
39	85	Courtney Yates	China, HvV
39	85	Monica Culpepper	One World, BvW
41	82	Ami Cusack	Vanuatu, Micronesia
42	81	Jenna Morasca	Amazon, All-Stars
42	81	Richard Hatch	Borneo, All-Stars
44	80	Corinne Kaplan	Gabon, Caramoan
45	79	Robert “Bob” Crowley	Gabon
46	78	Alicia Calaway	Aus. Outback, All-Stars
46	78	Terry Deitz	Panama
48	77	Jud “Fabio” Birza	Nicaragua
48	77	Kim Spradlin	One World
48	77	Yau-Man Chan	Fiji, Micronesia
51	75	Brandon Hantz	South Pacific, Caramoan
52	74	Brian Heidik	Thailand
52	74	Tony Vlachos	Cagayan
54	73	Kenward “Boo” Bernis	Fiji
55	71	Chris Daugherty	Vanuatu
55	71	Jessica “Sugar” Kiper	Gabon, HvV
55	71	Natalie Anderson	BvW2
58	70	Kat Edorsson	One World, BvW
58	70	Sophie Clarke	South Pacific
60	69	Kelly Wiglesworth	Borneo
60	69	Shii Ann Huang	Thailand, All-Stars
60	69	Yul Kwon	Cook Is.
63	68	Danni Boatwright	Guatemala
64	67	Rob Cesternino	Amazon, All-Stars
64	67	Yung “Woo” Hwang	Cagayan
66	66	Cassandra Franklin	Fiji
66	66	Chase Rice	Nicaragua
66	66	Earl Cole	Fiji
66	66	Susan Hawk	Borneo, All-Stars
70	65	Spencer Bledsoe	Cagayan
71	64	Ian Rosenberger	Palau
71	64	Stacy Kimball	Fiji
73	63	Andria (Dre) “Dreamz” Herd	Fiji
73	63	Keith Nale	BvW2
75	62	Albert Destrade	South Pacific
75	62	Becky Lee	Cook Is.
75	62	Matthew “Sash” Lenahan	Nicaragua
75	62	Matthew von Ertfelda	The Amazon
79	61	Brett Clouser	Samoa
79	61	Susie Smith	Gabon
81	60	Ashley Underwood	Redemption Is.
81	60	Chelsea Meissner	One World
81	60	Rafe Judkins	Guatemala
81	60	Twila Tanner	Vanuatu
85	59	Bobby Jon Drinkard	Palau, Guatemala
85	59	Kim Johnson	Africa
85	59	Natalie Tenerelli	Redemption Is.
85	59	Sabrina Thompson	One World
85	59	Stephen Fishbach	Tocantins
85	59	Todd Herzog	China
85	59	Vecepia Towery	Marq.
92	58	Carter Williams	Philippines
92	58	Clay Jordan	Thailand
92	58	Darrah Johnson	Pearl Is.
92	58	Grant Mattos	Redemption Is.
92	58	Neleh Dennis	Marq.
97	57	Jon Misch	BvW2
98	56	Denise Stapley	Philippines
98	56	Keith Famie	Australian Outback
98	56	Lisa Whelchel	Philippines
98	56	Natalie Bolton	Micronesia
102	55	Jaclyn Schultz	BvW2
102	55	Jason Siska	Micronesia
102	55	Rudy Boesch	Borneo, All-Stars
102	55	Troy “Troyzan” Robertson	One World
106	54	“Jonny Fairplay” Dalton	Pearl Is., Micronesia
106	54	Randy Bailey	Gabon, HvV
106	54	Reynold Toepfer	Caramoan
109	53	Denise Martin	China
109	53	Ted Rogers, Jr.	Thailand
111	52	Adam Gentry	Cook Is.
111	52	Burton Roberts	Pearl Is.
111	52	Cindy Hall	Guatemala
111	52	Edward “Eddie” Fox	Caramoan
111	52	Helen Glover	Thailand
111	52	Julie Berry	Vanuatu
111	52	Katie Gallagher	Palau
111	52	Latasha “Tasha” Fox	Cagayan
111	52	Mike Chiesl	Redemption Is.
111	52	Missy Payne	BvW2
111	52	Paschal English	Marq.
111	52	Sundra Oakley	Cook Is.
111	52	Trish Hegarty	Cagayan
124	51	Alejandro “Alex” Angarita	Fiji
124	51	Alicia Rosa	One World
124	51	Gregg Carey	Palau
124	51	Holly Hoffman	Nicaragua
124	51	Jane Bright	Nicaragua
124	51	Natalie White	Samoa
124	51	Peih-Gee Law	China
124	51	Reed Kelly	BvW2

Until next week…
Fish

Email: bryan.fish.fischer@gmail.com
Twitter: https://twitter.com/BF_TheFish
AIM: bryan.fish.fischer@gmail.com or Bryan Fischer

Pages: 1 2 3 4

4 thoughts on “SURVIVOR: WC vs BC vs NC – 3/4/15”

kinbville on March 8, 2015 at 12:58 pm said:

Happy B day Bryan! Loved the recap as always. I was really shocked Will voted out Vince. I think it was actually a bad move. Now that he did that, Will is going to be low man on the totem pole. Nina’s going to be mad and the Joe, Jenn and Hali alliance are going to pick he and Nina off unless he can make it to a merge. I would have voted Jenn off, but oh well. Nina was stupid to blab about Vince to Will bc it made Will vote out Vince and Vince was her biggest ally. As for the nudity, its just really gross. I’m especially shocked at Shirin. How totally embarrassing. So funny that the guys could not even look. Great Tom Dick and Harry reference BTW.
fishfischer on March 11, 2015 at 8:47 am said:

Hi Kinb, Thanks for the recognition. I can always count on you… As you know, I’m always shouting to keep your tribe strong at the beginning, so either the NCs are really dumb, or Vince was even creepier than we saw. Why else would you vote out someone IN YOUR OWN ALLIANCE? That is, assuming it was a Will-Vince-Nina alliance. Now, the next 2 tribals will be Nina, then Will, unless Joe has some epiphany about Jenn/Hali, or there’s a tribe swap. Just makes me wonder if players are ever given ANY info before the season, like…”Around the 10th day, there’s gonna be a tribe swap.” Probably not, but wouldn’t surprise me, and it wouldn’t surprise me that production secrets aren’t spilled by players…

Why would you have voted Jenn off? Do tell…

Ya know, with the nudity, here’s what I say. If you’re a dude, and you’re sporting a massive Johnson, and you’re single (that’s important!) and you know they’re gonna pixilate, then go Full Monty. Couldn’t hurt to advertise to the girls in the tribe, or maybe some “bonnie lass” on the crew, unless you think it’ll sway votes against you. For a woman, I don’t know if it’s so smart to show off the “Wicked Witch of the South,” especially with all the “flying monkeys” that come from no tweezers in camp. Ewww… Personally, I wouldn’t mind it. But that’s only because a long time ago I managed a strip club so I’m used to seeing women — some less than sexy — in their full glory, doing all those vile things that women do before they get on stage. And I had to discipline them for not upselling more Red Bulls…

And yeah, Tyler averting his eyes is like “don’t stare at Medusa, you’ll turn to stone.” I wonder what snakes were flying out of Shirin’s cooter region…
jlberry7 on March 11, 2015 at 3:05 pm said:

Love the ‘Freak Show’ moniker … and so appropriate! Not sorry to see him go, but will wonder about all the crazy s*** we’re gonna miss him saying! Thanks for providing my weekly laugh-out-loud moments … you’re a very funny man and spot-on with your observations!
fishfischer on March 12, 2015 at 2:09 pm said:

jlb! I wanna get this reply in before this week’s show/comments distract me from anything in the past. First, thanks for writing! And thanks for digging my stuff. Yeah, with only 44 minutes of show time each episode, you just gotta wonder how much craziness we never get to see. And like I mentioned in this week’s recap, you know players are saying crazy stuff, just to get more air time. I gotta believe that Freak Show was THROWING S**T OUT THERE to try and impress. Agree? Keep reading & laughing, I’ll keep trying to amuse… Thanks, Fish

You must be logged in to post a comment.

4 thoughts on “SURVIVOR: WC vs BC vs NC – 3/4/15”

Leave a Reply